Hodbarrow Mine fall of ground, 1919
On 5 September 1919 a slice of the limestone hanging wall fell in a working at Hodbarrow iron mine, Millom, and buried three men, two of them brothers. The inspector called it the most distressing fall of ground in the district for at least twenty-five years.
| Date | 5 September 1919 |
|---|---|
| Mine | Hodbarrow Mine |
| Region | Cumbria |
| Type | Collapse / Roof Fall |
| Fatalities | 3 (Three killed: Samuel George Boulton Crisp, 27, of Lonsdale Road, Millom, and the brothers George Richard Fallows, 49, and John Thomas Fallows, 42.) |
| Context | During active mining |
Location
Plotted at Hodbarrow Mine. Approximate location, low confidence. The large pin is the mine; the small round markers are the nearest mines on record. Click one for its page. View on full map
Cause
A big slice of the limestone hanging wall fell without warning. The sides of the vein were held by eight larch props wedged between the walls, timber that had stood through seven or eight idle years and had not been added to when the place was reopened.
Contributing factors
This part of the mine had been idle for seven or eight years until about three weeks before. The old timber looked good and was not supplemented, which the inspector judged, in the light of what followed, an error of judgment.
What happened
The three were taking out a small middling of ore from a vein about seven feet wide. Officials and workmen had examined the sides a few hours earlier and thought them perfectly sound; the place was regarded by both as one of the safest in the mine. The fall, put at twenty tons at the inquest, came down on all three.
Investigation & inquiry
The inquest returned a verdict of accidental death. The inspector's report for the year described the accident as happening under quite ordinary conditions.
Recorded claims
Individual factual claims, each attached to the source(s) that support it below. Where sources disagree, both are kept.
- On 5 September 1919 three men were killed at Hodbarrow Mine when a slice of the limestone hanging wall fell and buried them. 1,2
- The men were extracting a small middling of ore from a vein about 7 feet wide whose sides were supported by eight larch props. 2
- The section had been idle for seven or eight years until about three weeks before the accident, and the old timber was not supplemented. 2
- The inquest on George and John Fallows, brothers, and Samuel Crisp returned a verdict of accidental death; the fall was of twenty tons. 3
Related terminology
Mining terms this disaster is structurally linked to, with the nature of the relationship.
- Iron (contextual relationship)
Named in this record’s summary: “…a slice of the limestone hanging wall fell in a working at Hodbarrow iron mine, Millom, and buried three men, two of them brothers. The…” - Roof Fall (contextual relationship)
Named in this record’s summary: “…two of them brothers. The inspector called it the most distressing fall of ground in the district for at least twenty-five years.” - Vein (contextual relationship)
Named twice in this record, first in the cause: “…of the limestone hanging wall fell without warning. The sides of the vein were held by eight larch props wedged between the walls, timber that…”
Further reading
This page doesn't try to reproduce everything — these are the best original sources found for this disaster.
The inspector's account of the accident from the Mines Inspectors' Report for 1919, with the names and addresses of the three men.
View sourceSources
- (primary) Hodbarrow (Iron Ore) — Durham Mining Museum
- (primary) Hodbarrow (Iron Ore), 5th September 1919: fall of stone — Durham Mining Museum
- (secondary) Epitome of News (Abergavenny Chronicle, 19 September 1919) — Welsh Newspapers Online, National Library of Wales
Record created: 25 October 2026 · Last researched: 18 November 2026